Re: Know Your Gull Species

Wildlife

We're about more than just birds (though obviously we like them a lot).
RSPB Forum Thread with roles

Know Your Gull Species

Answered (not verified) This question has suggested answer(s)

Hi there

I have to admit that I find ID-ing gulls one of the most difficult things to do with bird watching

The Juvs 1st and 2nd year confuse me no end {confused}

I have posted some pictures of gulls some of which are easy to ID and others I struggle with

Love to hear what people have to say about them

Pictures posted next .. when the links are not so slow!

Regards

Kathy and Dave

All replies
  • Hi All,  I haven't a clue which gull is which (yet) but I know that they are thieving little devils.  When I was in Jersey a couple of years ago one stole my ice-cream.  It flew down and swiped it straight out of my hand.  I had only just bought it too.  It didn't even let me have a lick first!!!

    There is something new to learn everyday...

    http://www.flickr.com/photos/skylark58/

  • Sarum Bat

    Hi All,  I haven't a clue which gull is which (yet) but I know that they are thieving little devils.  When I was in Jersey a couple of years ago one stole my ice-cream.  It flew down and swiped it straight out of my hand.  I had only just bought it too.  It didn't even let me have a lick first!!!

    That was probably a Herring Gull as they are well known for this tactic especially when young children are involved!! 

    As a species I have never forgiven them for stealing my banoffee pie several years back when we were on holiday in St Ives (Cornwall), I can harbour a grudge for a long while where food is concerned.

    We were on the beach and had just got some cakes for dinner and as we were trying to organise 2 young children one of the evil creatures swooped down and had it out of the shopping bag.  After flying a few metres away, just far enough so it could still torment me it proceeded to remove the pie from the paper bag and eat it in front of my tear soaked eyes!!!!!!!

    I really must try and get over this event, but every time I eat banoffee pie I can't help thinking about the one that got away:-)

     

    "Feed the birds, tuppence a bag" Mary Poppins

  • Hi ND, Your story did make me laugh and thanks for identyfying my thief.  I'll think of you next time I have banoffee pie ;)

    There is something new to learn everyday...

    http://www.flickr.com/photos/skylark58/

  • Hi ND and Kezmo - me too!

    The necessity of bird-watching is a really good reason for avoiding all forms of housework.

    The dust will still be there tomorrow - the birds may not be!

  • As a good friend of mine once said

    "Waders 5 years, warblers take 10 years and gulls never"...

    The only way to master gull identifications is to be out there looking and obsevring them in the field. look for differences in structure and moult.

    Some of the larger gull species such as herring gulls have 5 plumage stages or ages i.e. Juvenile, 1st year - all the way up to 4th year birds, difficult enough yet? well within this, different birds moult at different stages dependant on there range in latitude. So pour example, birds breeding further south will generally commence breeding earlier than those further north, and so the post breeding moult will be observed at different times as well. If you were to sight a very tidy brilliant white looking herring gull at the moment its more likely in fact a yellow-legged gull. Our resident herring gulls are still in moult and will be more dusky and tatty in appearance.. hope that makes sense! :)

    Suggested by
  • Clear as mud Lloyd! ;-)

    (Joking of course! It makes sense, but doesn't help me much I'm afraid! Lol!!)

    "All weeds are flowers, once you get to know them" (Eeyore)

    My photos on Flickr

  • hi Lloyd

    Waders 5 years, Warblers take 10 years and gulls never EEEK ... LOL ....... now that is a great way of expressing how we know our birds. 

    I was told it takes 5 years to really know 'ALL' your bird species so i will now extend that a little further LOL {hehe}

    I have seen the Yellow Legged Gulls abroad in Spain and they are quite distinctive.  As as you say they are white as a gull can get.  The Auduion's is a easily noted Gull because of its beak colour (adult)

    The famous ones I get totally confused with are the Common Gulls and the LBB Gulls as they look the same shade of pale Grey to me. Same applies to the Meds and the Black Headed Gulls with the head colouring

    I did not know that the gulls take different times to moult depending where they are in the UK.

    So big question are the Juvs in my pictures on this thread all Juv Herring Gulls and which year?

    Regards

    Kathy and Dave

    LloydScott

    As a good friend of mine once said

    "Waders 5 years, warblers take 10 years and gulls never"...

    The only way to master gull identifications is to be out there looking and obsevring them in the field. look for differences in structure and moult.

    Some of the larger gull species such as herring gulls have 5 plumage stages or ages i.e. Juvenile, 1st year - all the way up to 4th year birds, difficult enough yet? well within this, different birds moult at different stages dependant on there range in latitude. So pour example, birds breeding further south will generally commence breeding earlier than those further north, and so the post breeding moult will be observed at different times as well. If you were to sight a very tidy brilliant white looking herring gull at the moment its more likely in fact a yellow-legged gull. Our resident herring gulls are still in moult and will be more dusky and tatty in appearance.. hope that makes sense! :)

     

  • Love your stories everyone LOL - what a laugh we have with some of the antics of our birds.

    I remember being on the ferry boat going across to Isle of Arren and a Gull stole my sandwich right out of my hand.  I stood in shock, and my friends thought it was hilarious.

    It did not even hurt me so it was well trained with its habits.

    Wish i knew what type of gull it was but it was too quick for me!

    Regards

    Kathy and Dave

  • What a good topic, have lol at the stories.  I'D is difficult though isn't, it,    Remember as a child they were just  big Seagulls or  wee Seagulls.

  • Where I live we get a lot of greater black backed gulls and black- headed gulls.  For the GBB and LBB I go by the leg colour (although it isn't always easy to catch sight of) 

     

    Kelvingrove Museum in Glasgow has a wonderful key to identifying gull species.

     

    As for the criminal nature of the things, on the first day of our sumer holiday in Helston, Cornwall I was stalked for half an hour by a flock of GBBs whilst eating a bag of chips in the street.  Wife and 3 kids ran screaming into the distance amidst bemused locals but as I was hungry (we'd just driven from Lanarkshire overnight) I braved it.  I think I earned their respect......

    I even love magpies

    Suggested by
  •  

    Hi,

    Birdwatching magazine will be covering the ID of Mediterranean and Black headed Gulls in an upcoming issue.

    Mediterranean gulls are now breeding in increasing numbers following the massive increase in wintering numbers since the 1970s :))

    S

    Please state the nature of the birding emergency

  •  

    Hi,

    just found this post-

     

    1-  Common gulls- mostly adults

    2- Black headed gull on railing

    3- Black headed gulls and Herring gulls with feral pigeon

    4-  Great Black Backed gull

    5- Herring gulls

     

    :))

     

    S

     

     

     

    Please state the nature of the birding emergency

Page 2 of 2 (27 items) 12